When exhaustion becomes part of leadership culture

Exhausted female business leader resting her head on her hand with her eyes closed at an office desk surrounded by paperwork and a laptop.
Research published in Harvard Business Review examines how sleep deprivation affects leaders and the workplace expectations that surround it. Drawing on a survey of 1,009 US managers and executives, this article explores why many leaders underestimate the effects of insufficient sleep, how exhaustion becomes associated with commitment and what organisations can learn from studies showing the impact of leadership support on recovery.

When exhaustion becomes part of leadership culture

Sleep neuroscientist Els van der Helm describes a leadership team gathering to make one of its biggest decisions of the quarter.

The CEO hasn’t slept enough all week. She arrives looking energetic, coffee in hand, and nobody knows how tired she really is.

Van der Helm describes her as “performing alertness”. Around the table, others may be doing much the same.

It’s a familiar expectation in leadership. Whatever is happening behind the scenes, you’re expected to arrive ready and capable of making important decisions.

But how well can we judge our own performance when we’re running on too little sleep?

The gap between feeling capable and performing well

Van der Helm’s Harvard Business Review article, Research: Sleep Deprivation Is a Leadership Problem, draws on a 2026 survey of 1,009 US managers and executives.

Some 39% reported getting insufficient sleep at least four nights a week. Yet almost half believed inadequate sleep had little or no effect on their leadership performance.

Sleep deprivation can affect attention and the ability to evaluate information. These capabilities are central to leadership, particularly when decisions involve competing priorities or other people’s wellbeing.

The difficulty is that fatigue can influence the very judgement we rely on to recognise its effects.

A leader may feel perfectly capable of chairing a meeting or making a significant decision. Their confidence in that moment doesn’t necessarily tell them whether they’re operating at their best.

I’ve heard it called being “functionally intoxicated” with impacts being similar to driving over the legal alcohol limit.

The consequences can extend beyond the individual, particularly when others depend on the decisions being made.

When exhaustion becomes a sign of commitment

Six in ten leaders surveyed said their organisation regarded getting by on little sleep as a sign of commitment. That’s terrible!

In workplaces where that belief was common, 94% of leaders had concealed their tiredness at least once in the previous month.

Senior leaders were particularly likely to hide it repeatedly. More than half reported deliberately concealing fatigue from colleagues four or more times during that period, compared with 36% of leaders at lower levels.

The further people progress, the more they’re expected to appear capable and in control. Admitting exhaustion can feel inconsistent with that expectation.

Meanwhile, long hours and constant availability can gradually become associated with dedication.

People notice which behaviours receive recognition, particularly from senior leaders. Those observations shape their understanding of what is expected, even when nobody has explicitly said it.

The survey also found that 51% of leaders who felt unable to prioritise sufficient sleep within their organisation reported regularly getting too little of it, compared with 35% of those who felt they could.

Workplace expectations don’t explain every individual’s sleep habits, but they influence the choices people feel able to make.

When exhaustion is admired and tiredness is concealed, organisations lose an opportunity to recognise when demands have become difficult to sustain.

Can leadership behaviour change the outcome?

Van der Helm also discusses research showing how changes in leadership support can influence sleep.

In a randomised trial involving 39 US Army platoons, leaders received an hour of training focused on supporting sleep.

A month later, soldiers whose leaders had received the training were more than twice as likely to report getting over seven hours of sleep a night than those whose leaders hadn’t.

A separate study at a Fortune 500 IT company gave employees greater control over when and where they worked, alongside training for supervisors to better support responsibilities outside work.

Twelve months later, employees in the intervention groups reported longer sleep and fewer nights of insufficient rest than their colleagues in the comparison groups.

Both studies demonstrate the value of addressing working conditions alongside individual habits.

For organisations investing in leadership development, there’s a practical lesson here. The way leaders organise work and support their teams influences people’s ability to recover.

What are we making normal?

There will always be demanding periods in leadership. Some roles also carry responsibilities that require unusual hours or immediate availability.

The more difficult question is how those demands become understood as part of everyday working life.

What does your organisation recognise as commitment? How comfortable are people acknowledging that they’re tired? And when workloads become difficult to sustain, can they discuss that openly?

These questions may reveal more about a workplace than its formal wellbeing policies.

The intervention studies offer a useful place to start. Leaders can examine how work is scheduled, how much control people have over their time and whether recovery is considered when planning demanding periods.

For me, the most important implication of Van der Helm’s research is that sleep deserves a place in conversations about leadership effectiveness.

We spend considerable time developing leaders’ judgement and decision-making capabilities. It’s worth paying equal attention to the working conditions that allow them to use those capabilities well.

Gain your competitive advantage to have courageous conversations and clear, concise communication.​

Skip to content